My Simmons 22 mag is on my Ruger 77MKII been there for 7years next month.
It is a 3-9X32 also. Must be an earlier version of your new one BH. BAck then it was $55.00
The Simmons that came with my (Savage, its a mod 93-not 91) is a Deerfield 3-9x32 matte Bl. and look like the 22 Mag scope.I had it on the 223 for
a while and no problem with recoil.
As stated in your other post, depends on what you use it for. That being said, I had one like this on my 45/70 Marlin, worked great for a woods gun. I moved it to my GSR and forward mounted it Scout style and it works their as well. I mounted a Leverevolution scope on the Marlin to match the ammo.